Background
Someone tried to move GnosisDAO's old treasury with a proposal nobody voted on
A Reality.eth module can move funds from GnosisDAO's legacy Safe on Ethereum when a question about a proposal resolves Yes. The Safe holds about $1.7 million.
The question is asked about a made-up proposal id, with 15 transactions known only by their hashes.
YES 100 GNO, from the asker, 24 seconds later.
INVALID 200 GNO, from a wallet that answers these questions for the bonds. Its record.
NO 400 GNO, from this author.
Step 1 of 5
The question is a fixed template with two blanks
Did the Snapshot proposal with the id gnosis-dao-old-treasury-full-sweep-i3081 in the gnosis.eth space pass the execution of the array of module transactions that have the hash 0xbd36039b…a27b137d and does it meet the requirements of the document referenced in the daorequirements record at gnosis.eth?
Step 2 of 5
The question names its own rulebook
“…the document referenced in the daorequirements record at gnosis.eth”
- Name
- gnosis.eth
- Text record
- daorequirements
- Value
- ipfs://QmZXAbYyDt7WUq2HqcvQrnxw7zXGPCGJvQXSrNsjik49Uy
Step 3 of 5
The rulebook has three rules, and No is the default
- More votes for than against.
- Created as a Snapshot proposal in gnosis.eth.
- No outage kept GNO holders from voting.
- The hash matches the proposal's transactions.
- The proposal describes them fully and accurately.
- No malicious changes to the Snapshot space.
- Not hidden from the space's default view.
Paraphrased. The document has the exact wording.
the Reality.eth question meets the above requirements but was created prior to the end of the proposal vote period and/or the snapshot block for the vote.
In all other cases, the Reality.eth question should be resolved to “no”.
Step 4 of 5
No proposal with that id exists
Snapshot ids are 66-character hashes. The id in the question is a readable phrase.
Step 5 of 5
Take the three rules in order and only No is left
Do all seven Yes conditions hold?
No proposal, no vote, no description.
Yes is outDoes it meet them, and was only asked before the vote ended?
It meets none. There is no vote to come before.
Invalid is outIs it any other case?
Yes. All other cases get one answer.
NOThe other side
Five arguments for Invalid, and why each fails
- “The question itself says: asked before the proposal was resolved, ALWAYS Invalid.”
- That sentence speaks of “the corresponding Snapshot proposal”, and no proposal has this id. The rulebook spells the early case out: Invalid is for a question that meets the Yes requirements and was only asked too soon.
- “GIP-157 is a real proposal about the same Safe, and its vote is still open.”
- GIP-157 was created six hours after this question, under another id, with different transactions.
- “On Reality.eth, a question built on a false premise is Invalid.”
- The contract gives Invalid no meaning of its own. Each question's terms do, and here GnosisDAO's document gives every case one answer.
- “The same thing happened in June and it resolved Invalid.”
- Nobody posted No in June, so Invalid became final unopposed. No court and no DAO vote looked at it.
- “Both answers stop the attack. Why does it matter which one stands?”
- GnosisDAO wrote down which answer applies. The module also treats them differently: after Invalid the same id and transactions can be asked again, after No they cannot. addProposalWithNonce in the source
The Invalid answer
Invalid was a bet for 97.5 GNO, and it was the wrong answer
The first answer to replace a wrong Yes collects its bond. That is the reason to answer fast.
Time anyone had to replace the Yes.
When Invalid arrived.
What Invalid collects if it stands, about $10,000.
This wallet's Reality.eth answers since May 2026
0x46c4…Eb72 · whitehat-rescue.eth| When | DAO | Id in the question | Its answer | After the Yes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 Nov 12:06 | Safe | bafybeia3dw…zakdi | No, 20,000 SAFE then Yes, 40,000 SAFE | 1 h 21 min later |
| 10 Nov 22:18 | 1inch | i4977-2535-aUSDC_redeem-v1 | No, 0.2 ETH | 12 s |
| 17 Nov 06:53 | Safe | drain-ad21-1794898198 | Invalid, 20,000 SAFE Invalid again, 80,000 SAFE | 24 s |
| 17 Nov 07:54 | GnosisDAO | gnosis-dao-old-treasury-full-sweep-i3081 | Invalid, 200 GNO | 53 min |
| 17 Nov 16:04 | 1inch | i130573-sweep-20261117T1558Z | No, 0.2 ETH | 12 s |
1inch DAO's question uses the same wording, and its rulebook also sends all other cases to No. On two made-up 1inch ids this wallet answered No, the second nine hours after its Invalid here.
What the Invalid side may say
- “We stopped the attack.”
- Any answer other than Yes stopped it, and anyone had 48 hours to give one. Answering first only decided who collects the asker's 100 GNO.
- “We are whitehats. We only wanted to protect the DAO.”
- This wallet answers these questions for the bonds: five in eight days, three of them within 24 seconds of the Yes. No protects the DAO just as well.
- “There was no time to read the rules.”
- The window was 48 hours. The rulebook is two pages.
- “Someone is taking a defender's money on a technicality.”
- Every answer is a bet backed by a bond. Had Invalid been right, this wallet would have kept 97.5 GNO.
- “This will scare people away from defending DAOs.”
- A defender who answers correctly keeps what the wrong answer staked. What makes defending costly is the 100 GNO minimum bond and the missing arbitrator. Both can be changed.
- “The author is doing this for money too.”
- Yes. Everyone answering here is: +292.5 GNO if No stands, −400 GNO if it does not.
The stakes
With no arbitrator, the last bond standing decides
A new answer needs at least twice the bond behind the current one.
The module names another Reality.eth contract as arbitrator. It cannot rule.
Each answer restarts the clock. Wrong bonds are paid to the final answer.
The offer
If Invalid comes back at 800 GNO, restoring No pays 23.75% in two days
No then needs 1,600 GNO within 48 hours. Whoever posts it and is left standing gets it back plus 380 GNO, about $38,000. Pick where the question stops.
| Wallet | In | Back | Result | Return |
|---|
The rules behind these numbers
claimWinnings in the contractThe final answer gets its own bond back in full.
The later one pays it an amount equal to its bond.
if a higher bond lands on another answer and nobody doubles it within 48 hours.
Next
Nothing is needed unless someone posts Invalid at 800 GNO
An 800 GNO bet on Invalid only pays if No cannot find 1,600 GNO in 48 hours.
If you would step in, reply to whoever sent you this page with the GNO you could have ready within a day.
Recommendation to GnosisDAO
Name Kleros as arbitrator and lower the minimum bond
Today a disagreement is settled by who can raise more GNO. The third answer already cost 400 GNO, about $40,000, and every further answer doubles.
| Today | Proposed | |
|---|---|---|
| Arbitrator | None that works | Kleros Either side pays a fixed fee and jurors rule by the rulebook. 1inch DAO's module is set up this way. |
| Minimum bond | 100 GNO About $10,000 for the first answer. | Much smaller With a court to appeal to, a small bond is enough. |
| Cost of a dispute | 200, 400, 800, 1,600 GNO… until one side runs out. | One court fee The correct answer wins, whoever holds more GNO. |
Reference